Top Rated Used Cars for Sale in St. John's: 2025 Buyer's Guide
Top Rated Used Cars for Sale in St. John's: 2025 Buyer's Guide
Posted on July 15, 2025
Top-Rated Used Cars for Sale in St. John’s: 2025 Guide
Looking for a reliable vehicle that won’t break the bank? Buying a used car in St. John’s through Hickman Select is a smart choice. With new car prices continuing to rise, more and more drivers in Newfoundland are turning to used options that offer both quality and value.
At Hickman Automotive Group, our Hickman Select program gives you access to the best used vehicles available across all 9 of our locations. Whether you live in St. John’s, Clarenville, Gander, Carbonear or Burin, you’ll find a pre-owned vehicle that fits your needs and budget.
To help you narrow it down, we’ve put together this guide featuring the top-rated used cars that local drivers trust most.
1. Honda Civic
Why it’s a top pick: The Civic is one of the most reliable and fuel-efficient vehicles on the market. As a result, it’s become a favorite among students, commuters, and families alike. It’s easy to drive, low-cost to maintain, and holds its value well.
What to look for:
-
Apple CarPlay or Android Auto
-
Backup camera
-
Clean service records
Additionally, newer models often come with more advanced safety and tech features.
2. Hyundai Elantra
Why drivers love it: The Elantra offers great features at a price that’s easy on the wallet. Not only is it stylish, but it also includes comforts like heated seats and a smooth ride. Because of its fuel efficiency and modern design, it’s perfect for first-time buyers or those looking to save on gas.
Top features include:
-
Strong fuel economy
-
Bluetooth connectivity
-
Easy-to-use infotainment system
Moreover, you’ll find that many models are still under factory warranty.
3. Chevrolet Silverado 1500
Why it stands out in Newfoundland: If you’re looking for strength and durability, the Silverado delivers. Not only is it built tough for our rough roads and harsh winters, but it’s also ideal for towing, hauling, or heading to the cabin.
Best for:
-
Winter driving
-
Heavy-duty work
-
Recreational towing
Furthermore, many of our Hickman Select trucks come with rust protection and service records.
4. Toyota Corolla
Why it’s a safe bet: The Corolla is known for being one of the most dependable sedans ever made. Because of its simple design and excellent fuel mileage, it’s easy to maintain and cheap to run. In fact, many customers choose the Corolla for its long-term reliability.
Look for:
-
Toyota Safety Sense (on newer models)
-
Low kilometres
-
One-owner history
Plus, it’s a great option if you’re planning to keep your vehicle for several years.
5. Nissan Rogue
Why it’s a local favourite: With its available all-wheel drive and roomy interior, the Rogue is a fantastic SUV for Newfoundland weather. Whether you’re commuting to work or heading on a road trip, the Rogue keeps you comfortable and in control.
Perfect for:
-
Families
-
Outdoor adventures
-
Winter roads
In addition, many models include advanced safety features and remote start—ideal for cold mornings.
Why Buy from Hickman Select?
When you choose Hickman Select, you’re choosing a name Newfoundland has trusted for over 100 years. Every vehicle in our used inventory goes through a complete inspection before it hits the lot. That means you get the confidence of a quality vehicle without the high price tag.
Even better, we make it easy to shop across all 9 Hickman Automotive Group locations. If your ideal vehicle is located in another town, we’ll bring it to your nearest Hickman dealership.
With us, you’ll enjoy:
-
Clear, no-hassle pricing
-
Fair trade-in values
-
Flexible financing options
-
Friendly, local service from start to finish
As a result, you’ll spend less time worrying and more time enjoying your new ride.
Start Shopping Today
Finding your next vehicle doesn’t have to be stressful. With our Hickman Select inventory, you can shop online, book a test drive, or stop by your local dealership to see what’s in stock. Most importantly, our team is here to help you every step of the way.